When five college friends reunite, one night changes their lives forever. When Faina Andropov visits New Orleans with four college friends, it's to honor the death of their friend, Lisette. The five have never resolved the guilt they feel over Lisette's death, and decide to make a wish at Marie Laveau's tomb on Halloween. Faina and her friends become separated, and she is kidnapped by demon brothers Alexei and Konstantin Veselov and held prisoner in their mansion. As she becomes their lover, she learns that Alexei and Konstantin are bound by a contract with the devil, and she is both their key to freedom, and the love they must sacrifice to become human again. With the help of a fallen angel, the brothers find a way out of the contract. But before they can execute it, Faina is attacked by their enemies. Can they rescue her in time, or will they be forced to make the ultimate choice?