Sometimes, nothing can be done to stop the past from coming back to haunt you. When the man who kidnapped Sarah Jacobsen a few months ago is tossed in jail, rumors abound about revenge. Sarah's terrified, and her nightmares return worse than before. The two men, Liam Richland and Mason Sax, who watched over her after that fateful incident, fear Sarah's life might be in danger and insist she move in with them. Sarah fears she might fall for them but knows there is no way two hunky men would ever want a dumpy math teacher. Then her favorite professor from high school is murdered, and everyone believes this is a sign to her. Now more than ever, the men are determined to find out who wants to harm the woman they're falling hard for. Too bad Sarah has no idea who she can trust. How can they keep her safe and love her at the same time?