Ashley Vaughn just broke up with Nic Walker and Sylas Hayes in Chicago. They don't understand that she can't choose between them. The truth is she wants and needs them both. She returns to Destiny with a broken heart and buries herself in her work at the law firm and her studies for the bar exam. Nic and Sylas come to Destiny for a job offer at the very firm Ashley works for. They each want to win her back, but still on their terms. The two of them were once close, but no more. Dating the same woman tore them apart. Though they learn more about the unique makeup of the families in this unusual town, they still cannot come to terms with sharing Ashley. Dangerous facts began to surface that a killer wants to remain hidden. Ashley tries to resist falling deeper in love with Nic and Sylas, believing her heart will be ripped apart if she fails.