It's Valentine's Day and Tonya Paul would love to celebrate, but it's a day she'd rather forget. Ironically, she makes chocolate novelty items called "Heart Puzzles" that have become the new necessary Valentine's Day gift. She has no idea that her co-worker and former boyfriend, Sean McHenry wasn't going to let another day go by without telling her the truth. Sean's plan is desperate, but after a year of waiting for Tonya to get a clue, he's done with patience. It will take a lot more than rope and brute force to get her to listen, but he's willing to use both to get to the truth. It's a heart puzzle he believes is worth piecing together. The question is whether Tonya will break his heart in the end.