Catherine Morris leads a dull life as a companion to a wealthy young woman. To escape, she reads gothic novels. She dreams about two mysterious men loving her, and when she meets Henry Tilman and John Thorne, her heart recognizes them. John and Henry agree they'll each court Catherine and let her choose. Henry invites her to the Tilman's ancient family home, Norrington Abbey, and John comes along. At Norrington Abbey, Catherine discovers Henry's father's secret chamber filled with whips and cuffs and sees him and Henry's brother sharing a maid. Can she have her two men at once? John and Henry gladly share their passion with her. When Henry's father learns she's poor, he orders her to leave. Will Catherine lose the loves she's only just discovered? Or will John and Henry fight to give her all the intrigue and passion she desires for the rest of her life? Note: There is no sexual relationship or touching for titillation between or among the men.