Cosmetician Hunter Monroe is the busy single father of a precocious one-year-old son, Chase. When his nanny gets married and resigns, Hunter is left in the lurch until his best friend suggests the short-term solution of using their family's babysitter while interviewing new candidates for the position. To Hunter's surprise, his friend's solution turns out to be handsome twenty-three-year-old male college student, Terry.
While more of the applicants for the position fail to meet Hunter's expectations, the temporary babysitter impresses with his cooking skills and childcare knowledge. Chase makes the decision that Terry is the one he wants, but has Hunter also grown attached to the attractive babysitter?