Mike is about to start his dream job as managing owner of a hotel in Montauk, NY, but his focus shifts when he finds out Devon, his high school crush, is part of his new life. Devon has become an artist with her own retail store, specializing in jewelry made from sea glass, and she is stunned to find Mike taking over the old hotel. Though she's drawn to him, she is hesitant to begin a relationship with her past experiences still haunting her. The girl who turned him down has turned into the woman of his dreams. Can Mike convince Devon he's right for her in all the ways she never expected?