Toronto Maple Leaf captain Nathan Vaughan and his wife have been looking for a third for years, but Nathan's intense possessiveness has prevented them from having the menage experience they both dream of. When rookie Jeremy Reiner joins the team, they both think they may have found the man for them. Jeremy has never questioned his sexuality before. He has always desired women, and when Nathan and Rachel invite him to their bed, he quickly takes them up on their offer. Much to his dismay, and confusion, Jeremy finds himself falling in love with both Rachel and Nathan. The lovemaking is explosive, but is it enough to keep the three of them together when conflicting emotions, rumors, and genuine fears threaten to tear them apart?