Bethany Mattson has made up her mind that she wants to have a child. The trouble is, there is no man in her life. Her idea is to interview three men from her past and choose one whom she will ask to sign a legal document releasing him from monetary and parental obligation, after which she promises a single night of sexual bliss with her - all in the name of procreation. Julian Malone, a high-powered, single, handsome New York attorney, has been given Bethany's request. Through a comedy of errors and misunderstandings, Julian believes that Bethany and her good friend Lynda are living in an alternative lifestyle, and while he agrees to complete the documents he can't understand why he is so taken with a woman who is obviously unattainable to him.